Narrative Therapy for Relationships: Are You Stuck in the Same Old Story?

By Amanda LaMela

When navigating relationship uncertainties, we tend to tell ourselves incomplete stories. For compelling examples, look no further than Showtime’s Couples Therapy. We meet Michal and Michael in season 2, and their relational scripts reveal themselves immediately. Michal becomes furiously expressive, and Michael passively withdraws. In the third episode, a smile from Michael is enough to set Michal off. She wants to know what he could possibly find funny. He freezes, unable to answer.

By this point, anyone watching can predict how the next few minutes will go, and so do Michal and Michael. Michal’s story is easy to follow because she tells it loudly. Her anger is about the life she expected and believes he has failed to provide. According to Michael’s story, nothing he does will ever be enough for her. She yells, and he freezes. She takes his stillness as proof that he doesn’t care. Her aggravation escalates, so he retreats a little further. The subject of their fight might change from week to week, but the conflicts follow familiar patterns.

Watching Couples Therapy as a therapist, I quickly notice this couple’s commitment to their respective roles. She is the angry one with high standards. He is more easygoing and will inevitably fall short of her expectations. Each partner can produce years of evidence for this. Each new argument adds to the narrative, while any exceptions are reflexively dismissed. The afternoon he took charge of something, or the night she was gentle with him, are quickly forgotten. These moments just don’t fit into the story each of them has created.

Narrative therapy offers a novel perspective. What if some relationship challenges are shaped by the stories we've developed about ourselves and our partners? Narrative therapy treats the story as the couple's central problem. Once a story hardens, it distorts our perceptions and dictates what we notice about the other person. You have probably never screamed at your partner on television, but you likely know how it feels to be stuck in a relational loop. Maybe you bring up something that bothers you and your partner gets defensive. You try to explain yourself more carefully, but somehow that makes things worse. Before long, you're having the same argument you've had a dozen times. Your partner might say that you are "too sensitive." You tell your partner that they "never listen." You've each developed a pretty convincing case for why the other person is responsible for the problem. At some point, these descriptions can become so familiar that they start to feel like facts.

How Our Relationships Become Stories

Human beings are natural storytellers. We organize our experiences into narratives that help us understand ourselves, other people, and the world around us. In relationships, these stories begin forming almost immediately. We notice patterns, assign meaning to behaviors, and develop expectations about how someone will respond. Early in a relationship, we might describe a partner as independent, spontaneous, or passionate. A few years later, we might interpret those same qualities as emotionally distant, unreliable, or temperamental. Of course, people change. Sometimes our perceptions change because the other person’s behavior has genuinely shifted. However, our interpretations are also shaped by accumulated experiences, disappointments, and assumptions.

Take a look at Nessa and Drea from season 5. They find themselves trapped in problem-saturated stories they’ve co-authored over 20 years. Nessa feels restricted by the relationship and desires more personal freedom. Drea feels neglected, left behind, and unappreciated. Eventually, the couple finds themselves locked into rigid roles that influence how they treat one another. Nessa views herself as “more evolved” and sees Drea as overly dependent and stagnant. Drea has committed to her role as “the good wife” and views Nessa as selfish and avoidant. Each person begins anticipating the other's behavior through the lens of that story. A request for quality time might feel like criticism. An evening alone might be interpreted as rejection. As these expectations become more entrenched, the couple responds more to their accumulated history than to what's happening in the present moment.

What Is Narrative Therapy?

Developed by Michael White and David Epston, narrative therapy is a collaborative approach to psychotherapy that explores how personal stories shape our identities, relationships, and experiences. These stories develop through our interactions with family, culture, society, and important people in our lives. Certain experiences become especially influential, while others receive less attention. For example, someone who grew up feeling dismissed by their family might develop a story that their needs are unimportant. Years later, that belief could influence how they interpret a romantic partner's behavior, particularly during moments of disagreement. Narrative therapy helps people become curious about these established interpretations. First, your therapist will help you explore where these stories originated and how they influenced behavior. Together, you will then unearth any experiences that complicate or contradict these rigid scripts.

Another important concept within narrative therapy is externalization, which involves separating people from their problems. The problem is discussed as a separate entity. In a 2024 article published in the Journal of Indian Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health, researchers Jagatdeb and colleagues explored how externalizing conversations helped young people examine internalized shame and negative beliefs about themselves. The authors demonstrated how creating distance between a person and their problem can create opportunities to explore alternative understandings of their experiences. Although the research focused on young people rather than romantic couples, the underlying principle has meaningful applications to relationship difficulties. Instead of approaching a disagreement assuming one partner is the problem, a couple might begin examining the patterns that repeatedly create distance between them. This creates room for curiosity, compassion, and accountability.

Rediscovering the Relationship Beneath the Conflict

When a relationship has been difficult for a long time, conflict can begin to dominate how both people remember it. The arguments are easy to recall. Moments of tenderness, cooperation, or playfulness may feel increasingly distant. Narrative therapy can help people explore a fuller history of their relationship, including experiences overshadowed by conflict.

A 2023 case study published in the Journal of Clinical Psychology explored this approach with a highly conflicted separating couple. Researchers Montesano and colleagues described a narrative therapy-informed intervention that encouraged the partners to reconnect with values that had once been important to their relationship. Rather than beginning with another examination of their grievances, the clinicians invited the couple to reflect on the relationship's history, guiding principles, and meaningful experiences. Through relational interviewing, reflecting-team conversations, and therapeutic letter-writing, the couple began reconnecting with values such as understanding and respect. The researchers described a meaningful shift toward greater relational awareness.

What Does Narrative Therapy Look Like in a Session?

Narrative therapy can be incorporated into both individual and couples counseling. Sessions generally involve collaborative conversations in which a therapist helps clients explore the stories influencing their experiences and consider alternative perspectives. There is no requirement to arrive with a polished account of your relationship or succinctly defined needs.

A client comes to therapy feeling resentful because their partner rarely initiates plans together. They describe the situation by saying, "I'm obviously not a priority. If they wanted to, they would." A narrative therapist might begin by exploring what the client has come to believe about themselves and their relationship. When did you first start feeling like you weren't a priority? What happens between you and your partner when that feeling shows up? Together, the therapist and client might begin identifying moments that complicate the dominant narrative and uncover overlooked stories of warmth and care.

Narrative therapists like to look for exceptions to the script. They probe to unearth experiences that do not fit neatly into the established problem story. Someone who describes themselves as incapable of communicating might recall a moment when they expressed a difficult feeling clearly and felt understood. A partner who believes they always withdraw during conflict might remember a conversation in which they remained emotionally present despite feeling uncomfortable. By identifying unique outcomes, couples may start to develop a more nuanced sense of identity and possibility. Over time, the stories gain depth and intricacy. Once-rigid narratives will begin to include stories of growth, connection, and change.

Can Narrative Therapy Help You Feel More Connected?

The relationship between our personal narratives and feelings of connection extends beyond romantic partnerships. The stories we develop about ourselves can shape whether we feel worthy of attention or comfortable expressing our needs. A rigid, incomplete self-concept can erode our ability to recognize genuine care and affection.

Consider someone who has come to believe that they are inherently socially awkward and unlikeable. That belief will likely influence how they approach friendships and romantic relationships. They may hesitate to initiate plans, become highly sensitive to perceived rejection, or struggle to trust expressions of affection. Even positive interactions can become difficult to accept when they contradict an established self-concept.

Research suggests that narrative-based interventions may benefit certain experiences of loneliness. In a 2025 randomized controlled trial published in The American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, Jiang and colleagues examined a telephone-delivered narrative intervention designed to help older adults reflect on their life experiences and personal wisdom. The study involved 287 adults aged 65 to 90. Participants who received the narrative intervention reported significantly less loneliness than the control group receiving regular telephone calls, as measured by one of the study's loneliness scales.

The intervention was specifically designed for older adults, and the findings do not directly demonstrate that narrative therapy improves romantic relationships. Nevertheless, they contribute to a growing interest in how personal meaning-making and reflection may influence experiences of social connection. For people who struggle with persistent feelings of rejection, inadequacy, or disconnection, exploring their personal narratives may offer another way to understand the beliefs shaping their relationships.

Exploring Narrative Therapy at PAD Mental Health Counseling

Our histories, experiences, expectations, and the meanings we assign to them shape our relationships. When familiar patterns begin interfering with connection, therapy can provide a space to examine those dynamics with greater curiosity and understanding. At Present Authentic Development (PAD) Mental Health Counseling, narrative therapy is one of several therapeutic approaches available within our integrative practice.

Our clinicians work collaboratively with clients to explore personal experiences, relationship patterns, and the beliefs that shape their sense of self. Depending on your needs, this work may take place in individual or couples therapy. If you've been feeling stuck in familiar relationship dynamics, contact PAD to explore your therapy options. Sometimes, a new perspective can help you recognize possibilities that have been there all along.

References

Jagatdeb, S., Mishra, S., Bajpai, T., & Sen, S. (2024). “Externalizing the internalized”: Exploring externalizing conversations in narrative therapy with adolescents and young adults in the Indian context. Journal of Indian Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health, 20(2), 153–160. https://doi.org/10.1177/09731342241238096

Jiang, D., Tang, V. F. Y., Kahlon, M., Chow, E. O.-W., Yeung, D. Y.-L., Aubrey, R., & Chou, K.-L. (2025). Effects of wisdom-enhancement narrative-therapy and empathy-focused interventions on loneliness over 4 weeks among older adults: A randomized controlled trial. The American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry, 33(1), 18–30. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jagp.2024.07.003

Montesano, A., Madigan, S., Çakmak, K., Ness, O., & Brønseth, S. R. (2023). Reconnecting with relational values in highly conflicted separating couples: A narrative therapy-informed relational interviewing teamwork-based supervision approach. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 79(6), 1521–1536. https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.23480

Next
Next

When Your Mind Turns Against You: Challenging the Negative Voice of Depression